AD8302ARUZ-RL7 vs AD8304ARUZ-RL7

Dieser detaillierte Vergleich von AD8302ARUZ-RL7 und AD8304ARUZ-RL7 bietet wertvolle Einblicke in deren Spezifikationen und Hauptmerkmale. Wir gehen ausführlich auf wichtige Faktoren ein, darunter RoHS-Konformität, REACH-Status, Serie, Montageart, Gehäusetyp und weitere relevante Eigenschaften. Die übersichtliche Darstellung der Unterschiede vereinfacht die Komponentenauswahl und erleichtert Ihnen die Wahl der optimalen Lösung für Ihre Anwendung.

Technical review by ETEI Component Engineering Source: manufacturer documentation

Replacement verdict

Not a drop-in replacement

The AD8304ARUZ-RL7 and AD8302ARUZ-RL7 are not drop-in replacements for one another. Although both are analog logarithmic detectors in the same TSSOP-14 package, they differ fundamentally in function: the AD8304 is a single-channel 160 dB logarithmic converter optimized for photodiode current measurement, while the AD8302 is a dual-channel gain and phase detector intended for RF/IF signal-chain analysis. Their input topologies, output types, and application domains are distinct, so substitution requires full circuit redesign and validation.

Different output type Different channel count Different input topology Different application domain

Parts at a glance

Key differences

Rows are prioritized by design impact. Highlighted values require attention during substitution.

Key electrical and mechanical differences between the two devices

Parameter AD8304ARUZ-RL7 AD8302ARUZ-RL7 Why it matters
Function Logarithmic converter (log amp) RF/IF gain and phase detector The core function differs fundamentally; one measures signal magnitude logarithmically while the other measures gain and phase between two signals, so they are not functionally interchangeable.
Frequency Range DC to 160 MHz (input bandwidth) DC to 2.7 GHz Operating frequency range determines whether the part can be used in a given signal chain; the AD8302 covers much higher RF frequencies.
Dynamic Range 160 dB (logarithmic) 60 dB (gain/phase measurement) Dynamic range defines the span of signal levels the device can accurately process; the AD8304 offers a much wider logarithmic range.
Output Type Logarithmic voltage output Gain (magnitude) and phase voltage outputs The output signal format must match the downstream ADC or processing circuitry; these parts produce different output quantities.
Number of Input Channels 1 (single-ended) 2 (dual input for ratio measurement) The AD8302 requires two inputs to compute gain and phase, whereas the AD8304 processes a single input signal.
Supply Voltage 3.0 V to 5.5 V 2.7 V to 5.5 V Supply voltage compatibility affects whether the part can drop into an existing power rail design.
Package 16-lead TSSOP 14-lead TSSOP Package and pin count affect PCB footprint and layout; different packages are not drop-in compatible.
Typical Supply Current ~4.5 mA ~28 mA Supply current impacts power budget and thermal design; the AD8302 draws significantly more current.

Need help validating a replacement?

Send your BOM and application constraints for technical and sourcing review.

Full specification comparison

Use manufacturer datasheets as the final authority.

Specification AD8302ARUZ-RL7 AD8304ARUZ-RL7
Part Status Active Active
Frequency 2.7GHz -
RF Type General Purpose -
Input Range -60dBm ~ 0dBm -
Accuracy ±0.5dB -
Voltage - Supply 2.7V ~ 5.5V -
Supply Current 23 mA -
Mounting Type Surface Mount Surface Mount
Type - Logarithmic Converter
Applications - Fiber Optics

Frequently asked questions

What are the primary functional differences between the AD8304ARUZ-RL7 and AD8302ARUZ-RL7?

The AD8304ARUZ-RL7 is a single-channel, 160 dB logarithmic detector/controller optimized for fiber optic photodiode measurement, providing a logarithmic output proportional to input current over a wide dynamic range. The AD8302ARUZ-RL7 is a dual-channel RF/IF gain and phase detector that measures the amplitude ratio and phase difference between two input signals, operating over a frequency range from LF to 2.7 GHz. They serve fundamentally different measurement functions and are not functionally interchangeable.

Do the AD8304ARUZ-RL7 and AD8302ARUZ-RL7 share the same package and pinout?

Both devices are offered in a 14-lead TSSOP package (RU-14 suffix), but their pin functions and internal architectures differ. The AD8304 provides logarithmic current-to-voltage conversion with pins for photodiode input, VLOG output, and reference/buffer outputs, while the AD8302 provides two RF input channels, phase and magnitude outputs, and reference/offset pins. PCB layouts and pin assignments are not interchangeable between the two parts.

What is the specified operating frequency or input range for each device?

The AD8304ARUZ-RL7 is specified for logarithmic current input spanning approximately 100 pA to 10 mA (160 dB dynamic range) and is intended for DC-coupled photodiode monitoring rather than RF signal processing. The AD8302ARUZ-RL7 is specified for AC-coupled RF/IF inputs from low frequency up to 2.7 GHz, measuring gain/loss and phase between two channels. The input domains (photodiode current versus RF voltage) are not directly comparable.

Can the AD8302ARUZ-RL7 be used as a drop-in replacement for the AD8304ARUZ-RL7 in a photodiode measurement circuit?

No. The AD8302 is a dual-channel RF gain/phase detector requiring two AC-coupled RF inputs and does not provide the wide-range logarithmic current-to-voltage conversion or the photodiode bias/interface features of the AD8304. Substitution would require a complete redesign of the signal chain and is not supported by the manufacturers' datasheets.

What are the typical supply voltage and current consumption specifications for these devices?

Both the AD8304ARUZ-RL7 and AD8302ARUZ-RL7 operate from a single supply in the 3 V to 5.5 V range, with typical supply current in the range of approximately 20 mA to 30 mA depending on configuration and output loading. Designers should consult the respective manufacturer datasheets for exact quiescent current, output drive, and derating specifications before finalizing power budgets.

Are the AD8304ARUZ-RL7 and AD8302ARUZ-RL7 RoHS compliant and available in tape-and-reel packaging?

Both part numbers carry the "Z" suffix indicating RoHS-compliant lead-free construction, and the "-RL7" suffix indicates tape-and-reel packaging in 7-inch reels. Buyers should confirm current compliance status and packaging quantities against the manufacturer's latest product data and distributor listings, as compliance declarations and reel quantities can be updated.

Which device is appropriate for RF power amplifier gain and phase monitoring, and which for optical power measurement?

The AD8302ARUZ-RL7 is intended for RF/IF gain and phase monitoring, such as in power amplifier linearization and VSWR measurement, because it directly outputs magnitude ratio and phase difference between two RF channels. The AD8304ARUZ-RL7 is intended for optical power measurement and photodiode monitoring, providing a logarithmic voltage output proportional to photodiode current over a very wide dynamic range. Selection should be based on the physical quantity being measured (RF voltage ratio/phase versus photocurrent).

What output signal types do these two devices provide?

The AD8304ARUZ-RL7 provides a logarithmic voltage output (VLOG) proportional to the logarithm of input photodiode current, along with buffered reference outputs for interfacing to ADCs. The AD8302ARUZ-RL7 provides two analog outputs: one proportional to the magnitude ratio (gain/loss) between its two RF inputs and one proportional to their phase difference. The output semantics and scaling are entirely different and must be interpreted per each datasheet.